Appearance
0036: Positioning, and staying a software tool outside AML supervision
Context
GetMy Books is to be sold to tech-savvy UK owner-directors on Xero, used from Claude through MCP, at £19.99 per company per month (billing: ADR 0037; self-service sign-up: ADR 0038).
- Anti-money laundering supervision. The Money Laundering Regulations 2017 (MLR 2017) reg 11 define an "external accountant" as a firm or sole practitioner who provides accountancy services to other persons by way of business. Accountancy service providers must be supervised for AML (by a professional body or HMRC). Guidance from the Institute of Financial Accountants reads software as outside this when the vendor does not itself prepare or analyse financial information for its customers: the customer uses the tool, and the vendor supplies the tool.
- Liability. Customers are third parties. A wrong figure acted on could lead to a claim. The way the product describes itself sets what a customer can say they were promised.
- Earlier wording called GetMy Books a "virtual accountant" that "prepares and files returns" (vision, README, owner guide, docs site). That reads as an accountancy service, and as a promise of advice.
Decision
1. Positioning
The line used everywhere the product describes itself:
Check your Xero books from inside Claude. It lists what looks wrong, with the records behind each finding so you can confirm it in Xero; nothing changes until you approve it; each check says what it did not cover.
Amended 2026-10-13 by the Product Owner, for the 1.0.0 launch. The line was "Finds what's wrong in your Xero books before your accountant or HMRC does". The ADR 0038 review dropped that promise of an outcome from the sign-up pages (a test forbids it there), so the line here, the README, the landing page (ADR 0040) and the docs now say what the software does, not what it gets ahead of.
Words we do not use about GetMy Books, in docs, tool descriptions, marketing or the terms: "virtual accountant", "independent", "verified", "assured", "audited", "guarantee", "advice", "we prepare your VAT" (or any "we prepare / we file / we do your books" phrasing).
Use instead: "checks", "finds", "flags", "shows the records behind", "proposes", "you approve", "you file". Telling the owner to ask their accountant is fine and stays.
Existing tool names (vat_verify_return, vat_prepare_return and the rest) stay: renaming breaks connected clients. Their descriptions say what the code checks, not that anything is verified or assured.
2. Five rules that keep GetMy Books a software tool
- No human service. Get My Books Ltd staff never view, review, prepare, correct or analyse a customer's books, even with the customer's permission. Support is for the software only (sign-in, connection, errors, how a feature works). It never views customer books data: it diagnoses from the customer's own description and from service logs, which hold no books data, and it does not ask for or use screenshots of the books (amended 2026-10-09, aligned with terms 1.2 and DPA 2.2).
- The owner does everything. The software finds and proposes; the owner decides and approves each change in Xero, in an approval card the model cannot press (AUDIT C5).
- A software tool, not a service. Every page, term and description speaks of software the customer uses, never of work done for them.
- No filing. GetMy Books does not file with HMRC or Companies House. The owner or their accountant files. The recognition plan (
docs/plans/hmrc-and-companies-house-recognition.md) stays unapproved, and SPEC-002 (VAT filing) is not built while this ADR stands. Filing is ondocs/not-doing.md. - A self-service software licence. Customers accept a software licence on sign-up (
docs/legal/terms-of-service.md), not a contract for services. Acceptance is an explicit tick-box that the app records (who, when, which version of the terms), never implied by signing in; ADR 0038 specifies it.
3. Liability stance
The terms and the product wording say the same thing:
- Findings are things to check, not advice. The customer confirms each one in Xero before relying on it.
- The customer is responsible for their books, their filings and every change they approve.
- The software is provided as is.
- Liability is capped at the greater of £1,000 and the fees the customer paid in the 12 months before the claim (amended 2026-10-12), with no liability for indirect or consequential loss. Nothing limits liability for death or personal injury from negligence, for fraud, or to data subjects under UK GDPR Article 82.
4. Before the first paying customer (blocking)
Amended 2026-10-12 by the Product Owner, after the legal research and the review of the drafts (PR #257).
- Legal sign-off. The Product Owner, as director of Get My Books Ltd, reviews and approves the drafts in
docs/legal/and this ADR's reg 11(c) and 11(d) analysis (section 5), recorded here with the date; the "DRAFT" banners come off then. A solicitor's review is a later improvement, not a blocker (Product Owner, 2026-10-12: no spending before revenue). Done 2026-10-12: approved by Rob Duncan, director, through the Product Owner; the documents are in force from that date (PR #257). - Retention. Account deletion, and revoking and deleting a company's Xero tokens, are built and tested (SPEC-017, migration 0019). The scheduled deletes for the ADR 0026 periods are built and tested before the first record reaches its period, not before launch: the earliest, write previews, by 30 November 2026 (issue #258). The documents state the periods as commitments. 2026-11-03: previews (issue #258, migration 0020) and the six-year deletes (issue #295, migration 0034) run on the server's sweep. 2026-11-04, Decided 2026-11-04 by the Product Owner (chat) (the ADR 0026 amendment of 2026-11-03, issue #295, QD-35, PR #360): the former-customer company delete (90 days after both the subscription ended and the Xero connection went, the later date; never a comped company; migration 0036) and the person delete run on it too, as the documents say. The clock starts at deploy: no company is deleted until 90 days after the deploy that switches these deletes on.
- Hosting. FEAW Services Ltd, whose NAS runs production and holds the backups, is listed as a subprocessor under the written hosting and sub-processing agreement in
docs/legal/feaw-hosting-agreement.md, signed by both parties before the first paying customer. Done 2026-10-12: approved for both by Rob Duncan, director of each. There is no off-NAS backup destination today (Hyper Backup is not installed). - ICO. Get My Books Ltd pays the data protection fee (Tier 1) and its registration number goes into the privacy notice. Done: registered as ZC149074 since 16 May 2026, renewal due by 15 May 2027.
- The ADR 0024 checklist (Xero limits, insurance) still applies.
5. Tax adviser (MLR 2017 reg 11(d)) (added 2026-10-12)
Reg 11(d) makes a "tax adviser" an AML-supervised business: a firm or sole practitioner who by way of business provides "material aid, or assistance or advice, in connection with the tax affairs of other persons" (https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2017/692/regulation/11). This sits beside the reg 11(c) external accountant analysis above, and the answer is the same.
Why GetMy Books is outside it. The customer runs a self-service software tool. It flags possible VAT coding errors and lists records for the owner to confirm in Xero. It never files, never gives advice, and no person at Get My Books Ltd acts for the customer. The aid, assistance or advice about the customer's tax affairs is therefore not provided to "other persons" by the firm. The customer does it for their own business, with a tool the firm licenses. The firm supplies software, not a tax service.
What would bring it inside. Any one of these needs a new ADR and a solicitor's view first:
- a person at Get My Books Ltd reviewing or preparing a customer's figures, or correcting their coding;
- filing a return or any document with HMRC or Companies House for them;
- giving advice on tax treatment, or telling a customer what they should do about their tax;
- acting as the customer's agent, such as an HMRC agent authorisation or a Xero practice login.
Product wording rules that follow. Say "checks", "flags" and "lists". Never say "advises", "assists with your tax" or "prepares your return for you". This adds to the words list in section 1 and applies to docs, tool descriptions, marketing and the terms.
Professional view. A professional view on reg 11(c) and (d) may be sought later, as section 4 already requires a solicitor to confirm the position. HMRC's AML supervision guidance is at https://www.gov.uk/guidance/money-laundering-regulations-who-needs-to-register.
Consequences
- README, CLAUDE.md, the vision, the owner guide and the docs site are reworded to the positioning line.
docs/not-doing.mdgains "Human bookkeeping, review or advice service" and "Filing to HMRC or Companies House".- If GetMy Books ever adds a human service or filing, it re-enters the AML question: that needs a new ADR that supersedes this one, and the solicitor's view first.
- FEAW and WealthTechPros, the owners' own companies, are never billed (ADR 0037); they use the same software on the same terms of use.