Skip to content

Plan: owner-director money decisions ​

Status: plan, awaiting the Product Owner's approval; no code yet.

Why ​

The decisions an accountant is paid to advise on are the ones that go wrong quietly: a director's loan account left overdrawn at the year end, a dividend paid without the profits to cover it, Corporation Tax that nobody put aside. Each costs real money (a 35.75% charge, a dividend that must be repaid, a tax bill the bank balance cannot meet), and none shows up as a deadline until it is too late. GetMy Books already reads the ledger and knows the year ends (SPEC-004). This plan turns that into running figures the owner can act on.

It serves both companies: FEAW (runs payroll) and WealthTechPros (no employees, its owners take dividends). It moves SM-2 (savings identified and acted on) and protects SM-1 (a missed s455 or Corporation Tax payment is a penalty).

Scope needs a decision first. The capability model has "Corporation Tax and accounts" (CAP-02.4) and "Director's personal position" (CAP-03.2) as post-MVP. This plan covers only the company side: figures from the company's own books, and documents for the company to sign. The director's own tax return stays post-MVP (CAP-02.6). Where a figure needs the director's personal position (dividend tax, the salary mix), it is shown as a worked calculation on figures the owner types in, never stored as a tax position and never filed.

House rules this plan keeps ​

  • Integer pence (ADR 0025), from pure functions in src/rules/. Each rate and threshold is a constant with effective dates and a source URL.
  • Every figure is labelled an estimate or a check, never a filed figure.
  • The entity comes from the session; new tables carry entity_id under RLS.
  • The one Xero write (the dividend journal) is preview then confirm by ID (M4), audited in ledger_write.
  • GetMy Books never pays, files or runs payroll (docs/not-doing.md); minutes and vouchers are drafts for the directors to sign.

1. Director's loan account (DLA) ​

What GetMy Books would show or do ​

  • The live balance of each director's loan account, from Xero, with the direction in words: "the company owes Rob £X" or "Rob owes the company £X".
  • The movements behind it: money taken, personal spending coded to the DLA, repayments, dividends or salary credited to it.
  • When overdrawn: a warning with the year end, the s455 charge that would arise if it is still owed then, the date that charge falls due, and the last date to repay to avoid it.
  • A bed-and-breakfasting check: any repayment near the year end that is followed (or planned to be followed) by new borrowing is flagged, because it will not count.
  • A benefit-in-kind flag when the balance owed passes £10,000 at any point in the tax year: the taxable benefit at the official rate, the P11D it needs, and the Class 1A National Insurance (FEAW's payroll deadlines are already on the radar, SPEC-004).
  • Repayment options, explained side by side: pay back in cash, declare a dividend credited to the DLA (section 2), or a bonus through payroll (FEAW only). A repayment that is itself taxed (dividend, bonus) is not caught by the bed-and-breakfasting rules.

Rules and figures ​

RuleFigureEffectiveSource
s455 charge on a loan to a participator still owed at the due date32.5%loans made before 6 Apr 2022gov.uk directors' loans
33.75%loans made 6 Apr 2022 to 5 Apr 2026gov.uk directors' loans
35.75% (the dividend upper rate for the tax year the loan is made)loans made on or after 6 Apr 2026CTA 2010 s455(2); ITA 2007 s8(2) as amended by Finance Act 2026
s455 due datethe day after 9 months from the end of the accounting period in which the loan was madesince 2010CTA 2010 s455(3)
Repaid after the year end but before the due dateno s455 payable (relief, shown on the CT600A)CTA 2010 s458; gov.uk
Repaid after the due dates455 reclaimable, not before 9 months after the end of the accounting period of repayment; interest on it is not repaidCTA 2010 s458(5); gov.uk
30-day rulerepayments of £5,000 or more and new loans of £5,000 or more within any 30 days: the repayment is matched to the new loan30 Oct 2024 onward (s464ZA, replacing s464C)CTA 2010 s464ZA; CTM61630
Arrangements rule£15,000 or more owed when repaid, with arrangements for £5,000 or more of new loans: the repayment is matched30 Oct 2024 onwardCTA 2010 s464ZA; CTM61635
Exceptiona repayment that is itself charged to income tax (dividend, bonus)CTA 2010 s464ZA
Beneficial loan thresholdtaxable if more than £10,000 owed at any time in the tax yearfrom 2014/15ITEPA 2003 s180; gov.uk
Official rate of interest3.75%2025/26 and 2026/27HMRC official rates
Class 1A National Insurance15%2026/27HMRC rates for employers 2026/27

Note: gov.uk's directors' loans page still says 33.75% on 2026-09-30. The legislation ties the rate to the dividend upper rate, which Finance Act 2026 raised to 35.75% from 6 Apr 2026. The code follows the legislation and cites both; each loan uses the rate for the tax year it was made in.

Data from Xero ​

  • Which account is the DLA. There is no fixed account in Xero. Common set-ups: one balance sheet account per director (a current liability that goes into debit when overdrawn, or a current asset), sometimes with separate "drawings" or "director's expenses" accounts beside it. Personal spending on the company card is coded straight to the DLA; repayments come in on the bank feed coded to it. GetMy Books reads the chart of accounts (accounting.settings.read, held), proposes the likely account from its name and type, and the owner confirms it once. The choice is stored per entity (dla_account: entity_id, xero_account_id, director name, confirmed by, confirmed at). Nothing is guessed silently.
  • Balance at a date: the trial balance or balance sheet report (accounting.reports.trialbalance.read or .balancesheet.read, new).
  • Movements: the Journals endpoint for that account (scope to confirm: accounting.journals.read), so every entry type is caught: spend money, receive money, manual journals, bills. New scopes mean a Xero reconnect (ADR 0024).
  • Year end: already known from Companies House (SPEC-004).

Edge cases ​

  • DLA in credit: no s455, no benefit; the director can draw it tax-free.
  • Two directors, or a shareholder's relative: one account each; loans to an associate are caught by s455 too.
  • Several loans across tax years at different s455 rates: repayments are matched to loans oldest first (to confirm with a professional) and each remaining loan carries its own rate.
  • A DLA spread over several accounts: the owner picks all; they are summed.
  • Loans written off: treated as a distribution for the director and Class 1 National Insurance through payroll. Flagged "take advice", not calculated.
  • Year end not yet in Xero's lock date: balances can still change; the answer says "as at today, before year-end adjustments".

2. Dividends ​

What GetMy Books would show or do ​

  • A reserves check before any dividend. Profits available for distribution: retained profits from the last annual accounts, plus profit since (from Xero's P&L), less the estimated Corporation Tax on that profit (section 3), less dividends already declared since. It shows each line and says whether the proposed dividend fits.
  • If it does not fit on the last annual accounts, it says interim accounts are needed (Companies Act s836, s838) and that Xero's management figures must be reasonable enough to judge profits, losses, assets, liabilities, provisions, share capital and reserves. It never says "you can pay this" when the check fails.
  • Draft documents for the directors to sign: board minutes declaring the dividend (even with one director), and a voucher per shareholder. Minutes show the date, directors present, the reserves figure relied on and the accounts it came from, the amount per share and class, and the payment date. Vouchers must show the date, company name, the shareholder's name and the amount (gov.uk); good practice adds share class, number of shares and amount per share.
  • Declared date and paid date kept apart. An interim dividend (the usual director-decided kind) is treated as paid only when actually paid; a final dividend is a debt when declared, or from the payment date it names (CTM15205). The tax year a dividend falls into follows that date.
  • The ledger side: once minuted, an optional dividend journal (write, preview then confirm): debit the dividends account, credit each shareholder's DLA. The bank payment is made by the owner and coded to the DLA from the feed. This is also how a dividend repays an overdrawn DLA.
  • Personal tax, as a worked figure only: the dividend allowance and rates for the year, applied to a total income the owner types in. Not stored, not filed; the director's return stays post-MVP (CAP-02.6).

Rules and figures ​

RuleFigureEffectiveSource
Distributions only out of profits availableaccumulated realised profits less accumulated realised lossesCA 2006 in forceCA 2006 s830
Relevant accountslast annual accounts; interim accounts if those do not support it; initial accounts in the first periodCA 2006 s836, s838
Unlawful dividenda member who knows, or has reasonable grounds to believe, must repay it; usually treated as a director's loanCA 2006 s847; gov.uk director hub
Minuteskeep minutes of the meeting that declares it, even with one directorgov.uk taking money out
Voucher contentsdate, company name, shareholder names, amountgov.uk taking money out
Dividend allowance£5002025/26 and 2026/27gov.uk tax on dividends
Dividend ordinary rate10.75% (8.75% in 2025/26)from 6 Apr 2026ITA 2007 s8; gov.uk
Dividend upper rate35.75% (33.75% in 2025/26)from 6 Apr 2026ITA 2007 s8; gov.uk
Dividend additional rate39.35%unchanged since 2022/23ITA 2007 s8; gov.uk
Personal allowance£12,570, reduced by £1 for every £2 of income over £100,0002026/27gov.uk income tax rates
Basic rate band / additional rate threshold£37,700 / £125,140 (England, Wales, NI)2026/27gov.uk income tax rates

Data from Xero ​

  • Retained earnings and current year earnings: balance sheet report (new scope, as above).
  • Profit since the last accounts: P&L report (accounting.reports.profitandloss.read, new).
  • The last annual accounts' reserves: the owner confirms the figure from the filed accounts (Companies House holds the filed PDF; micro-entity accounts may not show the P&L). Stored with the date and who confirmed it.
  • Shareholders and holdings: typed in once by the owner, checked against Companies House's persons-with-significant-control bands where available. Personal data under ADR 0026.

Edge cases ​

  • Several share classes (alphabet shares): amount per share per class; the check works on the total.
  • A dividend declared but not paid by the year end: counted against reserves, shown as owed in the DLA.
  • Year-end adjustments not yet posted (depreciation, accruals, the CT provision): the check says it uses management figures and shows the estimated CT it deducted.
  • Losses brought forward: reserves can be negative even with a profitable year; the check shows the cumulative figure.
  • WealthTechPros' owners share dividends: the documents list every shareholder, not only Rob.

3. Tax set-aside ​

What GetMy Books would show or do ​

  • A running estimate of Corporation Tax for the current accounting period: profit to date from Xero's P&L, annualised by days, the rate from the table below with marginal relief, and the full-period estimate.
  • "Set aside £X per month": the full-period estimate divided evenly over the period's months, and a catch-up figure: the share that should already be put aside for the days gone. Rounded up to the penny, so it never under-reserves.
  • Beside it, liabilities already known, not estimated: VAT for the open quarter (the draft from vat_prepare_return, FEAW), the VAT and PAYE/NI liability account balances in Xero, and the s455 figure if the DLA is overdrawn. Each with its due date from the deadline radar.
  • Every answer is headed "estimate, not a filed figure" and names the rule, the associated-company count used, and who confirmed it.

Rules and figures ​

RuleFigureEffectiveSource
Small profits rate19% on profits up to the lower limitFY2023 to FY2026 (1 Apr 2023 to 31 Mar 2027)gov.uk CT rates; CTM03910
Main rate25% above the upper limitFY2023 to FY2026as above
Lower / upper limit£50,000 / £250,000FY2023 to FY2026as above
Marginal reliefF × (U − A) × N ÷ A, F = 3/200FY2023 to FY2026CTM03925; CTA 2010 Part 3A
Associated companieslimits divided by (1 + number of associated companies)from 1 Apr 2023gov.uk marginal relief; CTA 2010 s18E
Short accounting periodlimits × days in period ÷ 365CTM03930
Period straddling 1 Aprildays in each financial year taxed at that year's ratesgov.uk CT rates
Payment9 months and 1 day after the period endSPEC-004; gov.uk
Quarterly instalments"large" above £1.5m, divided by (1 + associated companies)from 1 Apr 2023gov.uk CT instalments
FY2027 ratesto confirm when set; the code refuses to estimate days after 31 Mar 2027 at an unknown rate and says so

In the formula, N is taxable total profits and A is augmented profits (N plus exempt distributions from non-group companies). For our two companies A = N unless they receive dividends from other companies.

The associated-company test. Two companies are associated if one controls the other, or both are controlled by the same person or group of persons (CTA 2010 s18E; control as in s450 and s451). Control means holding, or being able to exercise, more than half of the votes or share capital, or rights to more than half of the income or assets on a winding-up. Where no one person controls a company, HMRC looks at the "minimum controlling combinations": the smallest groups of persons that together control it. Two companies are associated only if the same group is a minimum controlling combination of both (CTM03941). Rights of an associate (a spouse, relative or business partner) are added to a person's own only where there is substantial commercial interdependence between the companies: financial, economic or organisational links (CTM03950). Passive holding companies are excluded (CTM03945).

For Rob:

  • FEAW and WealthTechPros: if Rob (alone, or with the same co-owner in both) controls both, they are associated with each other, and each company's limits are halved: £25,000 and £125,000. This is the bigger question, because the vision calls Rob "the owner" of both.
  • Rob's other company (50%): 50% alone is not more than half, so Rob does not control it by himself. It is associated with FEAW only if the group that controls it (Rob and the other 50% holder) is also a minimum controlling combination of FEAW, or if the other holder is Rob's associate and the companies are commercially interdependent. On the facts known, it is probably not associated, but this is for the owner to confirm with a professional. GetMy Books stores the count and the reason, never infers it.

Data from Xero ​

  • P&L for the period to date (new report scope).
  • Adjustments the P&L does not make: add back depreciation and client entertaining, and use capital allowances instead (the owner types the capital allowances figure, or it is left out and the answer says so). Accounts to add back are chosen by the owner once, stored per entity.
  • VAT and PAYE liability account balances: balance sheet report.

Edge cases ​

  • Under 60 days into the period, annualising swings wildly: the answer says so and shows last period's CT beside it. Seasonal income: same caveat.
  • Loss to date: set-aside £0, and a note that losses may be carried forward.
  • First accounting period or a changed year end: period length from Companies House; limits reduced for a short period.
  • Associated count changes mid-period: the count at the end of the previous period applies (to confirm, CTM03956); the owner updates it.

4. Salary and dividend mix ​

What GetMy Books would show or do ​

An explained calculation, not advice. For a salary the owner picks (or a short list: £5,000, £6,708, £12,570), it shows:

  • employee National Insurance, employer National Insurance, and whether the Employment Allowance covers it;
  • the Corporation Tax saved because salary and employer NI are deductible;
  • the profit left for dividends, and the dividend tax on it at the director's rates, using income the owner types in;
  • the total cost to the company and the net received, side by side.

It shows the working for each line and ends with "confirm with a professional before changing payroll". GetMy Books does not run payroll (docs/not-doing.md); FEAW's payroll software applies any change.

Rules and figures (2026/27) ​

RuleFigureSource
Personal allowance / PAYE threshold£12,570 a year (£1,048 a month)HMRC rates for employers 2026/27
Lower earnings limit (counts for state pension)£6,708 a yearas above
Primary threshold (employee NI starts)£12,570 a yearas above
Secondary threshold (employer NI starts)£5,000 a yearas above
Upper earnings limit£50,270 a yearas above
Employee Class 1 (category A)8% between PT and UEL, 2% aboveas above
Employer Class 115% above STas above
Employment Allowanceup to £10,500 a year off employer NIgov.uk Employment Allowance
EA exclusiona company whose only director is the only employee paid above the ST cannot claimgov.uk EA eligibility
EA connected companiesonly one company in a connected group can claimgov.uk EA eligibility
Directors' NIdirectors have an annual earnings periodto confirm (HMRC CA44)

Which company can claim the Employment Allowance:

  • WealthTechPros has no employees. With one director it cannot claim; with two directors on payroll it may (to confirm how many directors are paid). It runs no payroll today, so any salary means registering as an employer.
  • FEAW runs payroll with more than one person paid, so it may qualify.
  • If FEAW and WealthTechPros are connected (the same control test, broadly), only one of them can claim. The owner confirms which.

Edge cases ​

  • Scottish taxpayers: different income tax bands; the tool asks and, for now, says "not covered".
  • The director has other income (a salary elsewhere, the 50% company's dividends): the personal allowance may already be used; the owner types total other income.
  • Income over £100,000: the personal allowance taper changes the answer.
  • Mid-year changes: the calculation is for a whole tax year; a part-year change is flagged.

5. Pensions from the company ​

Briefly, as a third option in the mix: an employer contribution to a registered pension scheme for the director is normally a deductible expense, so it saves Corporation Tax, and carries no employer or employee NI. It is allowable when paid wholly and exclusively for the trade; for a controlling director HMRC accepts it where the whole package is comparable with what an unconnected employee would get for similar work (BIM46035). The director's annual allowance is £60,000, tapered where threshold income is over £200,000 and adjusted income over £260,000, with unused allowance carried forward from the previous three years (gov.uk). Relief is given in the period the contribution is paid (to confirm).

GetMy Books shows the contribution as a line in the comparison (company cost, CT saved, nothing taxed now) and reminds the owner that money in a pension is locked until pension age. It never makes the payment.

MCP tools sketch ​

ToolKindDoes
director_loan_statusreadDLA balance, movements, overdrawn warning, s455 projection, B&B flags, BIK flag
director_loan_set_accountlocal write (our DB)Stores the owner's choice of DLA account; no Xero write
tax_set_asidereadCT estimate, monthly set-aside and catch-up, known VAT and PAYE liabilities, due dates
tax_set_associated_companieslocal writeStores the count and reason, with who confirmed it
dividend_checkreadReserves check for a proposed amount, with each line
dividend_documentsread (produces files)Draft minutes and vouchers for signature; stores the draft, sends nothing
dividend_journal_preview / dividend_journal_confirmXero write, M4Dividend journal to the DLA; confirm by preview ID only after the owner says yes; audited in ledger_write
salary_mix_comparereadThe side-by-side calculation for given salaries

ledger_write today needs a bank account and bank line on every row. The dividend journal needs it generalised (a write kind and a source reference) in a migration applied by the pipeline, not by hand.

Slices ​

Each slice is small, has its own spec scenarios, and ships alone.

  1. DLA balance. Choose the DLA account, read its balance and movements, overdrawn warning. New report scopes and a reconnect.
  2. Tax set-aside. CT estimate with marginal relief and associated companies, monthly set-aside, known VAT and PAYE liabilities.
  3. DLA year-end risk. s455 projection by tax year of loan, repayment deadline, 30-day and arrangements flags, BIK above £10,000.
  4. Dividend check. Reserves check and draft minutes and vouchers.
  5. Dividend journal. Preview then confirm; ledger_write generalised.
  6. Salary, dividend and pension comparison.

Recommended order: 1 and 2 first. They are read-only, need the same new scopes, and answer the two questions that cost most if missed.

Acceptance tests ​

Synthetic figures. Accounting period 1 Sep 2026 to 31 Aug 2027 (365 days).

  1. Overdrawn DLA. Given the confirmed DLA account shows the director owes £12,000 on 31 Aug 2027 and the loans were made after 6 Apr 2026, when director_loan_status runs, then it says s455 of £4,290.00 would be due on 1 Jun 2028 unless the £12,000 is repaid by 31 May 2028.
  2. Mixed rates. Given £4,000 lent on 1 Mar 2026 and £4,000 on 1 May 2026, both owed at the 31 Aug 2026 year end, then the s455 figure is £1,350.00 (33.75%) + £1,430.00 (35.75%) = £2,780.00.
  3. 30-day rule. Given £6,000 repaid on 20 Aug 2027 and £6,000 drawn on 10 Sep 2027, then the repayment is flagged as matched to the new loan and the £6,000 still counts for s455. Given the repayment was by a dividend credited to the DLA, then no flag.
  4. BIK. Given the director owed £14,000 on 6 Apr 2026 and £18,000 on 5 Apr 2027, when the tax year is checked, then the benefit on the average method is £600.00 and Class 1A £90.00, with the P11D and 22 July dates. Given the balance never passed £10,000, then no benefit.
  5. No DLA chosen. Given no account confirmed, then the tool lists the likely accounts and asks; it shows no balance.
  6. Set-aside, no associated companies. Given profit of £36,500 for the 146 days to 24 Jan 2027, then annualised profit is £91,250.00, CT at 25% is £22,812.50, marginal relief £2,381.25, estimate £20,431.25, set aside £1,702.61 a month, and £8,172.50 should already be put aside.
  7. Set-aside, one associated company. Same figures with one associated company: limits £25,000 and £125,000, marginal relief £506.25, estimate £22,306.25.
  8. Loss. Given a loss to date, then set-aside is £0.00 with a note.
  9. Dividend fits. Given retained profits of £20,000 in the last accounts, profit since £8,000, estimated CT on it £1,520 and no dividends since, when a £25,000 dividend is checked, then available is £26,480.00 and it fits. When £30,000 is checked, then it fails and says interim accounts are needed; no documents are drafted.
  10. Documents. Given a passed check, then the draft minutes name the reserves figure and its source, and each voucher shows the date, company name, shareholder and amount.
  11. Journal. Given a dividend of £5,000 to Rob, when the preview is shown and the owner confirms by ID, then one manual journal is created (debit dividends, credit Rob's DLA) and one ledger_write row; a second confirm with the same ID creates nothing.
  12. Salary. Given a salary of £12,570 in 2026/27, then employee NI is £0.00, employer NI £1,135.50, reduced to £0.00 where the Employment Allowance applies; given a single-director company with no other employee, then the allowance is not applied.
  13. Isolation. Given a user with access to WealthTechPros only, then no tool returns FEAW's DLA, reserves or estimate.
  14. Dates. Given a rate table, then every constant has an effective date and a source, and a date after the last known rate is refused, not guessed.

What stays with a professional ​

  • Whether companies are associated or connected, where ownership is shared.
  • Writing off a director's loan; loans to other companies or partnerships the director is in.
  • Interim accounts that will be relied on for a large dividend.
  • The final Corporation Tax computation and the CT600 (CAP-02.4, post-MVP).
  • The director's personal tax, including Scottish rates and the allowance taper (CAP-02.6, post-MVP).
  • Changing payroll or pension arrangements.

Decisions for the Product Owner ​

RefDecisionRecommendation
newBring the company side of these decisions into the MVP (a new capability or CAP-03.2 split), with a new spec per sliceYes, company side only; personal tax stays post-MVP
newWhich Xero account is each director's loan account, for FEAW and for WealthTechProsRob confirms once in the tool; GetMy Books proposes from the chart
newAre FEAW and WealthTechPros associated (does the same person or group control both)?Probably not: the Companies House register shows different people with significant control for each (see year-end-accounts-and-corporation-tax.md). Rob confirms; until then the estimate shows both results
newAre FEAW and Rob's other company (50%) associated?Probably not on 50% alone; Rob to confirm with the accountant, recorded with the reason
newWhich company claims the Employment Allowance, if connectedFEAW, since it runs payroll; accountant to confirm
newNew Xero scopes (P&L, balance sheet, trial balance, journals) and a reconnectYes, with slice 1
newCut-off below which the CT estimate is marked unreliable60 days into the period
newGeneralise ledger_write for journals not tied to a bank lineYes, in slice 5

Sources ​

All checked 2026-09-30.